Shaman Multiclass Mega Bug Report Thread
Moderators: Active DMs, Forum Moderators, Contributors
-
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Sat May 07, 2022 11:27 pm
Shaman Bard Synergy
Description
==========
Bard synergy appears to be no longer calculating as described.
With 23 shaman levels, and 3 bard levels, that should be putting the synergy at 10, and so 10 charges and access to custom songs.
23 divided by 3, comes out to 7.6
Therefore, 7 synergy levels.
7 synergy levels + 3 bard levels = 10.
Ever since this update, however, these have not been the case.
In fact, when it uses bard song, it seems to be using Selfish Solo, as I see all the buffs associated with that song. However, I cannot actually change the song. This becomes unfortunate for continued exploration of themes involving inspiration in the world, along with no longer having the mechanical text to compliment lyrics and poems.
Steps to reproduce
----------------------------
Re-level.
Use bard song, and attempt to change its type.
Expected result
-----------------------
10 charges of bard song, and ability to change custom songs.
Actual result
-------------------
9 charges of bard song, and while there is no ability to change which song is being played, it appears to be giving the benefits of Selfish Solo (probably the last one I had activated).
Screenshot(s)
--------------------
==========
Bard synergy appears to be no longer calculating as described.
With 23 shaman levels, and 3 bard levels, that should be putting the synergy at 10, and so 10 charges and access to custom songs.
23 divided by 3, comes out to 7.6
Therefore, 7 synergy levels.
7 synergy levels + 3 bard levels = 10.
Ever since this update, however, these have not been the case.
In fact, when it uses bard song, it seems to be using Selfish Solo, as I see all the buffs associated with that song. However, I cannot actually change the song. This becomes unfortunate for continued exploration of themes involving inspiration in the world, along with no longer having the mechanical text to compliment lyrics and poems.
Steps to reproduce
----------------------------
Re-level.
Use bard song, and attempt to change its type.
Expected result
-----------------------
10 charges of bard song, and ability to change custom songs.
Actual result
-------------------
9 charges of bard song, and while there is no ability to change which song is being played, it appears to be giving the benefits of Selfish Solo (probably the last one I had activated).
Screenshot(s)
--------------------
Shaman's Blood Frenzy
Description
==========
Blood frenzy malus to AC and Reflex does not carry over to server transition
Steps to reproduce
----------------------------
Cast blood frenzy (RAAAARGH!) and switch servers, the bonuses are retained, the downsides are not
Expected result
-----------------------
Have the AC and reflex Malus
Actual result
-------------------
Keeps only the bonuses, no Malus
Screenshot(s)
--------------------
Misc Notes
----------------
EDIT: Retransitioning to the server where Blood Rage does not resolve the issue, hence can be exploited if you have extended blood rage + Epic Transmutation (If you really want to, its more hassle than its worth though).
Which Server(s)?
------------------------
Surface - Guldorand
Gaming Platform(s)?
------------------------------
Windows
==========
Blood frenzy malus to AC and Reflex does not carry over to server transition
Steps to reproduce
----------------------------
Cast blood frenzy (RAAAARGH!) and switch servers, the bonuses are retained, the downsides are not
Expected result
-----------------------
Have the AC and reflex Malus
Actual result
-------------------
Keeps only the bonuses, no Malus
Screenshot(s)
--------------------
Misc Notes
----------------
EDIT: Retransitioning to the server where Blood Rage does not resolve the issue, hence can be exploited if you have extended blood rage + Epic Transmutation (If you really want to, its more hassle than its worth though).
Which Server(s)?
------------------------
Surface - Guldorand
Gaming Platform(s)?
------------------------------
Windows
Last edited by Ping14 on Tue May 10, 2022 5:59 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Arelith Platinum Supporter
- Posts: 1507
- Joined: Mon May 14, 2018 9:14 am
- Location: Mechanics Dungeon
Shaman Multiclass Mega Bug Report Thread
Please provide the following information in regards to your Shaman build and what is not working as intended:
- Shaman level
- Multiclass and their levels
- What mechanic is not working as intended
- Anything else you can think of
Re: Shaman Multiclass Mega Bug Report Thread
Description
==========
Ranger spells cast at a higher level than it should be
Steps to reproduce
----------------------------
Cast the spell and then check via the CL checking tool
Expected result
-----------------------
Be cast at CL4
Actual result
-------------------
Was cast at CL9
Screenshot(s)
--------------------
Misc Notes
----------------
Shaman level: 23
Multiclass and their levels: Ranger 4; Barbarian 3
What mechanic is not working as intended: Caster level seems to have affected cross class spellcasting aswell.
Anything else you can think of: Its either some wonkiness on the CL readout script, or it really did cast at CL9
Which Server(s)?
------------------------
Surface - Guldorand
Gaming Platform(s)?
------------------------------
Windows
==========
Ranger spells cast at a higher level than it should be
Steps to reproduce
----------------------------
Cast the spell and then check via the CL checking tool
Expected result
-----------------------
Be cast at CL4
Actual result
-------------------
Was cast at CL9
Screenshot(s)
--------------------
Misc Notes
----------------
Shaman level: 23
Multiclass and their levels: Ranger 4; Barbarian 3
What mechanic is not working as intended: Caster level seems to have affected cross class spellcasting aswell.
Anything else you can think of: Its either some wonkiness on the CL readout script, or it really did cast at CL9
Which Server(s)?
------------------------
Surface - Guldorand
Gaming Platform(s)?
------------------------------
Windows
-
- Arelith Platinum Supporter
- Posts: 1507
- Joined: Mon May 14, 2018 9:14 am
- Location: Mechanics Dungeon
Re: Shaman Multiclass Mega Bug Report Thread
A fix is in the pipeline.
Re: Shaman Multiclass Mega Bug Report Thread
Likely an unannounced rebalancing, placing it here just incase its not.
Description
==========
Shaman Multiclass CL reverted
Blood Frenzy lasting the default rounds/level despite extended and with ESF: Transmutation
Steps to reproduce
----------------------------
Cast the spell and then check via the CL checking tool
Expected result
-----------------------
Cast at 28 CL
Blood Frenzy lasting 4rounds/level + extended
Actual result
-------------------
Cast at default 23 CL
Screenshot(s)
--------------------
Misc Notes
----------------
Shaman level: 23
Multiclass and their levels: Ranger 4; Barbarian 3
What mechanic is not working as intended: Caster level reverted
Blood Rage only appears to be shorter but actually isnt. Still lasting to 3 to 4 extended haste.
Which Server(s)?
------------------------
Surface - Guldorand
Gaming Platform(s)?
------------------------------
Windows
Description
==========
Shaman Multiclass CL reverted
Blood Frenzy lasting the default rounds/level despite extended and with ESF: Transmutation
Steps to reproduce
----------------------------
Cast the spell and then check via the CL checking tool
Expected result
-----------------------
Cast at 28 CL
Blood Frenzy lasting 4rounds/level + extended
Actual result
-------------------
Cast at default 23 CL
Screenshot(s)
--------------------
Misc Notes
----------------
Shaman level: 23
Multiclass and their levels: Ranger 4; Barbarian 3
What mechanic is not working as intended: Caster level reverted
Blood Rage only appears to be shorter but actually isnt. Still lasting to 3 to 4 extended haste.
Which Server(s)?
------------------------
Surface - Guldorand
Gaming Platform(s)?
------------------------------
Windows
-
- Posts: 24
- Joined: Sat Jan 22, 2022 8:30 am
Re: Shaman Multiclass Mega Bug Report Thread
Since Blood Frenzy was mentioned, I wanted to add that having mighty rage, completely cleanses out both positive and negative effects. So does drinking a lesser restoration potion.
-
- Arelith Platinum Supporter
- Posts: 1507
- Joined: Mon May 14, 2018 9:14 am
- Location: Mechanics Dungeon
Re: Shaman Multiclass Mega Bug Report Thread
Can you try this on other servers?
Re: Shaman Multiclass Mega Bug Report Thread
Just tested myself after I saw this thread on Surface. CL is 23; Shaman 22, Ranger 4, Loremaster 4. Should, by the rules, be at least 27.
edit:
The extra 1 CL probably comes from loremaster.
edit:
The extra 1 CL probably comes from loremaster.
-
- General Admin
- Posts: 1494
- Joined: Thu Sep 28, 2017 10:34 am
- Location: Concourse Capaneus
- Contact:
Re: Shaman Multiclass Mega Bug Report Thread
This should be fixed next reset. Resto spells and abilities will ignore Blood Frenzy :)Akzeriuth900 wrote: ↑Sat May 14, 2022 10:05 pmSince Blood Frenzy was mentioned, I wanted to add that having mighty rage, completely cleanses out both positive and negative effects. So does drinking a lesser restoration potion.
Re: Shaman Multiclass Mega Bug Report Thread
Im Shaman 26 Monk 4 and only at CL 26 when it should be CL 28.
Cast spell resistance and it gives SR 38 (which is 12 + 26) and also the custom readout shows CL 26 after casting.
Monk levels arent providing any extra CL it seems.
Cast spell resistance and it gives SR 38 (which is 12 + 26) and also the custom readout shows CL 26 after casting.
Monk levels arent providing any extra CL it seems.
-
- Posts: 37
- Joined: Wed Oct 24, 2018 7:26 am
Shaman BAB boost seems broken
On wiki it states that shaman if majority is treated as a full bab class but not the 4th attack
"If Shaman levels are more than half of total level, the following applies:
The pre-epic BAB lost from not having full BAB progression is regained as soft AB. This does not increase APR.
Each and any multiclass now provides more synergy CL for the first 2 levels, then switches to 1/3 CL per level at the 3rd level and beyond. Different multiclass will stack for the extra 1/3 CL calculation purposes."
My character (20 shaman) with a dex mod of 7 and a +4 crossbow does not seem to get that benfit
BAB 15 + 7 + 4 = 26 ab in combat log
should be
BAB 15 + 7 + 4 + Soft BAB bonus of +5 = 31 Supposed ab
"If Shaman levels are more than half of total level, the following applies:
The pre-epic BAB lost from not having full BAB progression is regained as soft AB. This does not increase APR.
Each and any multiclass now provides more synergy CL for the first 2 levels, then switches to 1/3 CL per level at the 3rd level and beyond. Different multiclass will stack for the extra 1/3 CL calculation purposes."
My character (20 shaman) with a dex mod of 7 and a +4 crossbow does not seem to get that benfit
BAB 15 + 7 + 4 = 26 ab in combat log
should be
BAB 15 + 7 + 4 + Soft BAB bonus of +5 = 31 Supposed ab
Re: Shaman BAB boost seems broken
I believe that it applies only if you multiclass with full ab classes, such as fighter, ranger, etc.
If you check the examples on the wiki you will see that the shaman/monk combo does not get any extra sof ab.
If you check the examples on the wiki you will see that the shaman/monk combo does not get any extra sof ab.
-
- Arelith Platinum Supporter
- Posts: 1507
- Joined: Mon May 14, 2018 9:14 am
- Location: Mechanics Dungeon
Re: Shaman BAB boost seems broken
Yes, shamans will only obtain soft AB to refund the lost BAB if they multiclass into a full BAB class.
Wiki entry has been updated to reflect that.
Wiki entry has been updated to reflect that.
-
- Posts: 100
- Joined: Sat Oct 17, 2020 11:46 am
- Location: Denmark
Barb/Shaman CL way too high
yesterday I noticed on Skal that some spells lasted quite a while longer than expected so I checked the CL. For some reason my toon casts spells at CL 22 instead of 14 or 15.
https://imgur.com/a/T1zAk6C
https://imgur.com/a/T1zAk6C
"To every man is given the key to the gates of heaven. The same key opens the gates of hell" - Richard P. Feynman
-
- Posts: 56
- Joined: Tue Mar 10, 2020 8:44 pm
Possible Bug w/ Dispel Calculations on PGCC?
I am not sure if this is a bug, but it might potentially be one - if not, please accept apologies in advance.
Does anyone know about weirdness/bugs/known issues with how Dispelling is calculated on PGCC and / or live server?
Background:
Making a Shaman build using the various cross-class synergies:
21 Shaman
5 Ranger
4 monk
Per the wiki / "synergy calculations": CL is 27 vs. dispels, and then I have Arcane Defense: Abj., meaning my save should functionally be like a level 29 caster, for the purposes of dispel checks (https://wiki.nwnarelith.com/Dispel_Tables#Quick_Summary).
However...when I had a friend test things out, they hit me with a Greater Dispel (not even Mord's), almost all my wards dropped. They were casting as a level 24 bard / 5 loremaster, with no spell foci.
This seems...excessive (see image below). Like, I would assume that I lose some spells....but having such a massive number dispelled, from a character that is, for dispelling purposes, lesser level and without any sort of Spell Focus feats....seems wrong.
But, they don't include the dispel breakdowns in the combat log, there's nothing for me to check, here.
Does anyone know anything about this? Is this a glitch on PGCC? Is this how it works on the real server? Is there some known issue with the Shaman synergies / how that CL is being calculated, that means this is being calculated artificially low (I only have 21 actual Shaman levels).
I've tried testing over and over again...this keeps happening, so it doesn't seem like I just had an unlucky roll or two...seems to consistently occur.
To complicate things further, the "CL Checker" from the rest menu, keeps saying I'm CL 30, and my spell durations, confirm that it is treating me as CL 30 (Turns per level spells are lasting 30 minutes), when it shouldn't be, for regular casting (I should be CL 26).
So something is messed up....but I have no idea what, and if this is a broader issue on the actual server. Not clear if this is a PGCC issue, a "Shaman Synergy" issue, or some other mysterious spooky problem.
If anyone knows what might be happening here, then I'll provide a proper "bug report," but as of now, I can't say what the actual issue might be - any input would be extremely helpful.
Thanks!
Link to image of dispelled wards:
Does anyone know about weirdness/bugs/known issues with how Dispelling is calculated on PGCC and / or live server?
Background:
Making a Shaman build using the various cross-class synergies:
21 Shaman
5 Ranger
4 monk
Per the wiki / "synergy calculations": CL is 27 vs. dispels, and then I have Arcane Defense: Abj., meaning my save should functionally be like a level 29 caster, for the purposes of dispel checks (https://wiki.nwnarelith.com/Dispel_Tables#Quick_Summary).
However...when I had a friend test things out, they hit me with a Greater Dispel (not even Mord's), almost all my wards dropped. They were casting as a level 24 bard / 5 loremaster, with no spell foci.
This seems...excessive (see image below). Like, I would assume that I lose some spells....but having such a massive number dispelled, from a character that is, for dispelling purposes, lesser level and without any sort of Spell Focus feats....seems wrong.
But, they don't include the dispel breakdowns in the combat log, there's nothing for me to check, here.
Does anyone know anything about this? Is this a glitch on PGCC? Is this how it works on the real server? Is there some known issue with the Shaman synergies / how that CL is being calculated, that means this is being calculated artificially low (I only have 21 actual Shaman levels).
I've tried testing over and over again...this keeps happening, so it doesn't seem like I just had an unlucky roll or two...seems to consistently occur.
To complicate things further, the "CL Checker" from the rest menu, keeps saying I'm CL 30, and my spell durations, confirm that it is treating me as CL 30 (Turns per level spells are lasting 30 minutes), when it shouldn't be, for regular casting (I should be CL 26).
So something is messed up....but I have no idea what, and if this is a broader issue on the actual server. Not clear if this is a PGCC issue, a "Shaman Synergy" issue, or some other mysterious spooky problem.
If anyone knows what might be happening here, then I'll provide a proper "bug report," but as of now, I can't say what the actual issue might be - any input would be extremely helpful.
Thanks!
Link to image of dispelled wards:
Of course, optional horse death RP is a possibility.
Re: Possible Bug w/ Dispel Calculations on PGCC?
The caster level oddity is also occurring on the live server. I don't have someone to test dispels with at the moment to check if it has similar results.
Level 21 shaman/3 ranger/3 monk casting any spell from spellbook is getting duration/effect of CL30. Rest menu's CL check also says last spell cast was CL 30.
Casting an epic spell (planar conduit, epic dragon knight) reports last spell cast as CL21.
Level 21 shaman/3 ranger/3 monk casting any spell from spellbook is getting duration/effect of CL30. Rest menu's CL check also says last spell cast was CL 30.
Casting an epic spell (planar conduit, epic dragon knight) reports last spell cast as CL21.
-
- Posts: 56
- Joined: Tue Mar 10, 2020 8:44 pm
Re: Possible Bug w/ Dispel Calculations on PGCC?
Thanks for confirming (at least part) of the issue. I'll file a properly formatted bug report for this specific issue now that it's verified.Kelaris wrote: ↑Mon Sep 26, 2022 11:48 amThe caster level oddity is also occurring on the live server. I don't have someone to test dispels with at the moment to check if it has similar results.
Level 21 shaman/3 ranger/3 monk casting any spell from spellbook is getting duration/effect of CL30. Rest menu's CL check also says last spell cast was CL 30.
Casting an epic spell (planar conduit, epic dragon knight) reports last spell cast as CL21.
In the meantime, just wanted to add that I've spoken with a number of people who, anecdotally, have noticed the "Greater Dispel" seems to actually dispel significantly more spells than Mord's does.
Again, without dispel calculations being visible in the log, there's no way to confirm this (that I know of)....but if anyone out there has a way to look into this "scientifically," please let me know, I'd be happy to test.
Of course, optional horse death RP is a possibility.
-
- Posts: 56
- Joined: Tue Mar 10, 2020 8:44 pm
Caster Level Being Miscalculated in Rest Log (and Possibly in General)
Background:
For context, this was discovered while testing Shaman "synergy" builds against dispelling spells on PGCC. Part of what was observed was that the rest menu "Caster Level Report" was incorrectly reporting spell levels on PGCC as CL 30, even when they should not have been. As well, gauging by the duration of spells being cast from the spellbook, they were in fact being cast as level 30 spells (turns per level spells were lasting 30 minutes). Further testing seems to indicate that some variation of this issue is also occurring on the live server.
Link to original post: viewtopic.php?f=12&t=39350
Steps to reproduce:
- Build Shaman (21), Ranger (5), Monk (4) class. Effective CL for spellbook spells should be 26. (The specific build is not required - anything with Shaman "synergy classes" appears to have this issue on both PGCC and live server)
- Cast spell from spellbook
- Run the "CL Report" from the rest menu
Expected Result
- In the combat log, the CL from the spell cast should be CL 26
- Spell duration for turns/level should be 26 minutes
- For Planar Conduit, CL should be calculated as 26
Actual Result
- In the combat log, the CL from the last spell is reported as CL 30 when the spell is cast from the Shaman spellbook. (Both PGCC and live server)
- Spell duration is for CL 30 (spells with duration of turns / level last 30 minutes, or 60 minutes if extended - confirmed only on PGCC at this time).
- When tested with Planar Conduit, CL is listed as CL 21 when the Rest Menu report is run for the last spell cast (confirmed only on live server).
For context, this was discovered while testing Shaman "synergy" builds against dispelling spells on PGCC. Part of what was observed was that the rest menu "Caster Level Report" was incorrectly reporting spell levels on PGCC as CL 30, even when they should not have been. As well, gauging by the duration of spells being cast from the spellbook, they were in fact being cast as level 30 spells (turns per level spells were lasting 30 minutes). Further testing seems to indicate that some variation of this issue is also occurring on the live server.
Link to original post: viewtopic.php?f=12&t=39350
Steps to reproduce:
- Build Shaman (21), Ranger (5), Monk (4) class. Effective CL for spellbook spells should be 26. (The specific build is not required - anything with Shaman "synergy classes" appears to have this issue on both PGCC and live server)
- Cast spell from spellbook
- Run the "CL Report" from the rest menu
Expected Result
- In the combat log, the CL from the spell cast should be CL 26
- Spell duration for turns/level should be 26 minutes
- For Planar Conduit, CL should be calculated as 26
Actual Result
- In the combat log, the CL from the last spell is reported as CL 30 when the spell is cast from the Shaman spellbook. (Both PGCC and live server)
- Spell duration is for CL 30 (spells with duration of turns / level last 30 minutes, or 60 minutes if extended - confirmed only on PGCC at this time).
- When tested with Planar Conduit, CL is listed as CL 21 when the Rest Menu report is run for the last spell cast (confirmed only on live server).
Of course, optional horse death RP is a possibility.