Didn't get Masterful Recovery roll

[ltlukoziuz]

Description of Bug Experienced:
1) Tried making bolts of cloth, rolled 1 on one of them. However, I didn't get Masterful Recovery check on it, and so it instantly went ruined. My suspicion is that I had a godsave available and it tried to roll it instead, but because I have low piety atm (29.6%), it didn't actually trigger and so I got a fail.
2) Is more of a suggestion than bug, but currently, godsaves roll before masterful recovery check. Imo, it should first roll Masterful Recovery and only then Godsave

Steps to reproduce the Bug:
For 1:
Have Low Piety (29.6 when it happened), and enough Trade Skill to have chance for Masterful Recovery (20+ to DC)
Roll a 1 when crafting
For 2:
Have High Piety, and enough Trade Skill to have chance for Masterful Recovery (20+ to DC)
Roll a 1 when crafting

Expected Result:
In 1: Even if Godsave fails, Masterful Recovery should still be checked
In 2: Masterful Recovery is checked prior to Godsave

Actual Result:
No Masterful Recovery check is done

Screenshot(s)
1.
2.

[neverwinternightly]

EDIT: This is wrong.

In both of those screenshots, you don't have enough points in the skill for a masterful recovery roll.

The (20+ to DC) means your skill must be 20 points higher than the DC of the crafted object.

In the first screenshot, that would mean you need 25 points in tailoring.
In the second screenshot, you'd need 41 herbalism.

I'm not actually sure about the ordering of the masterful recovery and godsave stuff though. Not sure if that's actually a problem? I'd have to test a bit.

[ltlukoziuz]

I do. There's other screenshots I have where I do roll for MR. You only need to beat that, you don't need to actually have 20+ for MR. This is an example from different craft a few weeks ago:



I only have 18 Tailoring. I'm crafting 5 DC item (probably bolts of cloth too), so DC25 for MR - and I'm getting it.

However - I also have a spent godsave in this specific screenshot (because it was set of screens showing my 'bad' luck).

[neverwinternightly]

Weird! I could've sworn it was the case for MR. I must just be confusing it with needing 20 higher for mastery checks.

Sorry for the misinformation then!

[ltlukoziuz]

Weird! I could've sworn it was the case for MR. I must just be confusing it with needing 20 higher for mastery checks.

Sorry for the misinformation then!

The same with Mastery checks. Using the same above example of me brewing Heal potions (33 herb, 21 DC), I end up having 65% of passing Mastery check to save CP (41 DC, so need to roll 8+). Helps bloody lot in making enough stuff.